In a heartbreaking case that has shaken the Cedar City community, law enforcement officials have announced the arrests of four men in connection with the fatal shooting of 17-year-old KayLee Dutton. The arrests, made less than 24 hours after the tragic incident, represent a significant step forward in the pursuit of justice for KayLee and her family.
The Tragic Incident: Pursuit and Shooting
The events leading to KayLee’s death unfolded on January 17, 2025, at approximately 10:42 p.m. According to Iron County Sheriff Ken Carpenter, a red pickup truck carrying two teenage girls was pursued by another vehicle flashing its high beams. The chase began on Lund Highway, continued along Midvalley Road, and ended near the Three Peaks Recreation Area.
Ka’Niyah Baker Death & Obituary: Two Teens Arrested in Connection with Grisly Murder
The situation turned deadly when the suspect vehicle pulled alongside the red pickup and opened fire. “Several rounds were shot into the driver’s side of the vehicle, ultimately killing the driver,” Sheriff Carpenter reported. KayLee, who was driving, succumbed to her injuries shortly after being transported to Cedar City Hospital. Her passenger sustained a leg injury and is under medical observation.
Swift Arrests: A Coordinated Effort
Less than 24 hours after the shooting, Iron County Metro SWAT officers executed a search warrant at a townhome complex near Lund Highway, apprehending three suspects. A fourth individual was arrested at his workplace later that afternoon. Sheriff Carpenter expressed confidence in the arrests, stating, “We feel pretty good we have our suspects.”
The arrested individuals and charges include:
- Ethan Galloway and Michael Hess-Witucki: Charged with second-degree felony murder, 12 counts of felony discharge of a firearm, marijuana possession, and possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person.
- Matthew Sorber-Petrie and Aldric Felipe: Charged with obstructing justice, marijuana possession, and possession of a dangerous weapon.
Ongoing Investigation and Evidence Collection
The investigation remains active as law enforcement processes evidence from the crime scene and surrounding areas. On Saturday, Iron County search and rescue teams recovered at least one .223 caliber shell casing near Midvalley Road, believed to be linked to the shooting.
Sheriff Carpenter emphasized the thorough nature of the investigation, which includes processing the suspects’ apartment, analyzing the vehicle, and conducting detailed interviews. “We need to connect all the dots,” Carpenter said, highlighting the complexity of the case.
A Community in Mourning
The Cedar City community has come together to mourn the loss of KayLee Dutton, identified through social media tributes and crowdfunding campaigns. Described as a bright and kind-hearted young woman, KayLee’s untimely death has deeply impacted her family, friends, and neighbors.
Vigils and memorials have been held to honor her memory, with heartfelt tributes pouring in from across the community. A crowdfunding campaign has been established to support her grieving family, providing financial assistance during this difficult time.
Justice and the Road Ahead
As of January 19, formal charges against the suspects have yet to be filed in the 5th District Court. Sheriff Carpenter remains committed to ensuring justice for KayLee, stating, “I’m confident that we will bring the perpetrators of this crime to justice.”
Law enforcement is also working closely with KayLee’s injured passenger, who has yet to provide a formal statement. Authorities are prioritizing her physical and emotional recovery before conducting a detailed interview.
Addressing Gun Violence and Community Safety
This devastating incident has reignited discussions about gun violence and public safety in Iron County. Community leaders are calling for stronger measures to prevent such tragedies and to address the underlying causes of violence.
A local advocate shared, “This senseless act of violence highlights the urgent need for action. We must come together as a community to protect our children and ensure a safer future.”
Conclusion: Honoring KayLee’s Legacy
The arrests in KayLee Dutton’s case represent a critical step toward justice, but the journey is far from over. As investigators continue their work, the Cedar City community stands united in grief and determination, vowing to honor KayLee’s memory by seeking justice and fostering a safer future for all.
KayLee’s life, full of promise and potential, now serves as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of violence and the importance of collective efforts to create lasting change.